Why are we teaching students to write?

This title is intentionally provocative, but it is not rhetorical. Our question does not infer that we should stop teaching writing. The question is one we need to be asking ourselves and our colleagues in a way we have never had to before. For decades, we did not have to distinguish between teaching writing as preparation for work and teaching writing as a means of intellectual development. Generative AI has broken that alignment. 

Teaching students to write was always frustrating, important, and productive. Teaching them the mechanics of writing, helping them unlock their own gifts of prose, watching them struggle to fully articulate an idea that had half-formed over the course of a paper, a semester, or even years was important. Even for those of us who don’t love teaching writing, we understood this to be critical to their development. Writing was also important for their futures as employees authoring reports, as advocates writing letters to the editor or a city council, and in some cases, writing would be their careers as they went on to be journalists, speech-writers, or, tragically, academics.

One of the great things about teaching writing was that all of this went together. For a career-oriented student, we could compel them to practice the craft of writing by explaining the importance of it for the workforce and along the way, they developed as a reader, editor, and critical thinker. For the poets and creative writers in our midst we could sell them on writing as an expression of self, but by the end they also had a skill employers were clamoring for–critical thinking and clear writing. Sadly, this time has passed. We have been explicit about the role nostalgia plays for professors as we think about the past in the academy, the problem with this particular challenge is we have not named it. Instead, it is a feeling or a deeply held assumption that we now have to unpack for the first time.

We must ask the question “why are we teaching students to write” because the honest answer leads to different outcomes for the first time. If we are teaching students to write because it is a skill they need to be successful in the workforce then we must change how we teach them. Few employers are going to be interested in a student who can slowly produce blog posts, product descriptions, report summaries, or anything else that is simply a task to be completed the “old” way when using AI would be much faster. That student needs to have taste, they need to be able to discern good writing from bad, think about audience, and engage with an LLM, but sitting down to write in a way that we are authoring this article will not get the job done if you are tasked with writing dozens of reports in a single day. We are faster as reviewers and readers than we are as writers and that is the role that these students/employees will need to play. This does not mean they do not need to know how to write or that they should get to bypass first-year English, but if this is why we are teaching writing blue books are not the tool of choice.

On the other hand, if we are teaching students to write because we want them to develop as critical thinkers and learn to express themselves, we also have to change, but not in the same way. We have all heard colleagues say “thinking is writing and writing is thinking” which is inaccurate and reductionist. Non-literate societies and people have made important contributions to the development of thought for as long as there have been people. Writing is still important, but if expression and critical thinking are the goals other approaches are required. There is a world where in the name of critical thinking we may need to sequester students from technology. There are also interventions that remove writing from the central position when it comes to developing critical thinking and replace it with oral expression, active problem solving in groups or some other approach.

In the academy we have a somewhat romantic relationship with writing. A lot of us love doing it, teaching it, and even reading about teaching writing. This is true even though much of academic scholarship itself is not written well. The rupture caused by LLMs and some of the questions we are suggesting here mean we have to own up to the fact that most people in the world do not have this relationship with writing. Many of them loathed the idea of sitting down to write an essay on themes in The Great Gatsby just as they dread writing holiday cards and already outsourced that work to Hallmark decades ago. We have to recognize that for the general public, a Dan Brown novel represents excellent writing. If we pretend the world has the same relationship with writing that we do, we will end up even more out of touch than the harshest partisan caricatures of the spectacled professor writing in an ivory tower.

 We don’t pretend to know what approach matches your goals when you teach writing and we don’t intend this to be prescriptive, only provocative. We have to ask the question “why are we teaching students to write” even if we might not like the answers.


Next
Next

Unfixed Newsletter — October 29–November 11, 2026